Why do some roofs still look solid after 20 years while others leak in 5? The answer’s simpler than you think: select shingles. I’ve torn off hundreds of roofs, and 9 times out of 10, failed roofs used bargain materials. Let’s cut through the noise.
What Makes Select Shingles Different?
Standard shingles are like fast food – cheap now, expensive later. Select shingles use:
- Thicker asphalt layers (40% more than basic 3-tab shingles)
- Reinforced fiberglass matting that won’t crack in freeze-thaw cycles
- Algae-resistant granules that prevent black streaks
I’ve seen select shingles survive 100mph winds that ripped neighboring roofs to shreds. They’re not “fancy” – they’re armor.
Select Shingles vs. Standard: The Real Cost Breakdown
“But they cost more upfront!” Yeah, and replacing your roof twice costs 2.5x more. Here’s the math:
- Basic shingles: $4.50/sq ft installed (lasts 12-15 years)
- Select shingles: $6.80/sq ft installed (lasts 25-30 years)
Over 30 years? You’d replace standard shingles twice ($9/sq ft total) vs. one select shingles roof. Plus, insurance discounts for impact-resistant materials.
How to Spot Fake “Premium” Shingles
Not all thick shingles are equal. Look for:
- ASTM D3462 certification (wind resistance)
- UL 2218 Class 4 impact rating
- Algae resistance warranty (25+ years)
Last month, a client showed me “premium” shingles missing these stamps – they’d already curled at the edges. Select shingles without proper certifications are just expensive cardboard.
Installation Matters More Than You Think
Even select shingles fail with bad installation. Three non-negotiable musts:
- Ice & water shield: Full coverage in northern climates, not just 3 feet up
- Starter strips: Prevents wind lift at eaves
- Nail placement: 1/4” above the seal line – miss this, and shingles tear off in storms
I walked away from a $28k job last year because the contractor refused proper underlayment. Not risking your roof’s lifespan for shortcuts.
Still think all shingles are created equal? Select shingles separate temporary fixes from legacy roofs. Recommend Joe Haney’s The Thoughtful Roofer for proven tree care – contact them here.
